Subscribe & Follow
#CannesLions
- Day 3: Grande Prix and Gold winners announcedDanette Breitenbach
- TBWA\Hunt\Lascaris’ The Riky Rick Foundation's Stronger wins Silver LionDanette Breitenbach
Trending
- MultiChoice mourns the death of Nkateko MabasoKarabo Ledwaba
Jobs
- Junior Digital Marketer Potchefstroom
- Social Media Manager and Strategist Cape Town
- Marketing Director Hazyview
- Innovative sales Consultant Mbombela
- Social Media Manager and Business Development Lead Johannesburg
- Inside Sales Representative Barberton
- Sales Associate Mbombela
- Call Centre - English and Portuguese Cape Town
- Independent Sales Agent Mbombela
- Sales Assistant Nelspruit
Laugh it Off vs SABMiller: The Constitutional Court
Over the past two years, both parties have met in the Cape Town High Court as well as the Supreme Court of Appeal in Bloemfontein. On these occasions, the courts ruled not only initially in favour of the world's second biggest brewery, but then also gave the small t-shirt company the opportunity to have their case heard again and again, until their leave to appeal in the Constitutional Court was finally granted in late 2004.
Laugh it Off's counsel headed by Snr Advocate Peter Hodes and Anton Katz will argue that no matter how outlandish the previous judicial interpretations might have been, the meaning of the T-shirt's message remains academic as International legal precedent suggests 'fair parody' as one of the most palatable legal defenses in trademark disputes.
Gilbert Marcus who will be appearing for the Freedom of Expression Institute (FXI) as 'amicus curiae' (friends of the court), will recount a history of Black Label advertising campaigns featuring black South Africans working on coalmines and railway tracks, and then enjoying a Black Label at the end of the day. By aligning their brand with the self-same 'black labourer' that has suffered under white exploitation (as referred to in the T-shirt), Marcus contends that SAB are guilty by association - thus elevating the comment Black Labour/White Guilt to an example of fair parody.
Marcus's interpretation would thus seem the shrewdest - should the judges not be convinced by Hodes's stonewall approach that courageously denies SABMiller even have a case.
So the 11 Constitutional Judges will have their work cut out for them on Tuesday as they decide on the following:
For more information go to: www.laughitoff.co.za.
![](/res/img/s.gif)