
Subscribe & Follow
Jobs
- Senior Organisational Development Specialist Cape Town
- Ombudsman Western Cape
- HR Generalist Vereeniging
- MBA Graduate Opportunity Cape Town
Managers are carrying underperforming staff

6% percent of respondents said that they speak up on the first or second occasion to hold staff accountable when they miss targets or underperform, and 78% of South African managers believe they are 'skilled to very skilled' at handling performance conversations.
In spite of this, Helene Vermaak, Director and Business Owner of The Human Edge said that these crucial performance conversations often fail because of a mutual lack of perspective on the part of both employee and manager. According to the research, 70% of respondents believe that they see bad habits resurface within three months of a performance discussion and 66% believe they have to raise a concern two or more times to see an improvement in performance.
"It's only possible to create a high-performance culture through having the right performance conversations," said Vermaak. Using an iceberg as an analogy for organisational structure, Vermaak said that leaders focus on things like strategies, structure, plans and processes, which lie on the surface. "Many don't realise that it's what's going on below the waterline - the health of the cultural operating system itself -that underpins everything else, including performance."
The Human Edge's research also revealed the following findings:
The key to developing a healthy organisational culture lies in understanding the motivations and ability of employees and then managing the gap between expected and actual performance. Using the internationally recognised VitalSmarts methodology for Crucial Accountability, Vermaak explained that performance conversations need to be broken down into three stages - before, during and after.
According to Vermaak, the plan should roll out as follows:
"Rather than staking everything on the performance review itself, it's important for managers to realise that performance reviews are the culmination of all the feedback, discussions, and focused conversations you have with someone over a specific period of time," said Vermaak. "The actual performance review should simply be a recap of all the other regular feedback you have been giving your employee over time."
